Teaching to the Test: Lessons from the 2026 Higher Maths Exam

The 2026 Higher Mathematics examination attracted considerable criticism for its difficulty. In its subsequent response, the Scottish Mathematical Council (SMC) concluded that the papers were somewhat harder than those of the previous three years, but neither unfair nor inappropriate.

The SMC’s response raises an important question about how pupils prepare for examinations. Are they learning mathematics, or are they learning how to answer familiar types of examination question?

There is nothing inherently wrong with teaching to the test. Examination preparation necessarily involves practising past papers, mastering standard techniques and becoming familiar with the kinds of questions that examiners ask.

The danger comes when pupils learn to recognise question types without developing a sufficiently deep understanding of the mathematics involved. They may perform well on familiar questions but struggle when the same mathematics appears in an unfamiliar setting.

Good examination preparation should therefore go beyond rehearsing familiar solutions.

In my own practice the aim is to establish secure mathematical skills while also helping pupils understand why techniques work, how different ideas connect and when those techniques might be useful.

Ultimately, the best preparation for an unfamiliar mathematics question is a sound understanding of the mathematics itself.


Source: Scottish Mathematical Council — Response to the 2026 Higher Mathematics Papers